New patient volume is short of plan — dental groups

Thin pipeline — the phone rings and the chair stays empty

PRESENTATION — WHAT THE OPERATOR SEES

Calls and form fills are there. The schedule is not full, the hygiene column has holes, and the treatment that got diagnosed is not getting done. The owner describes it as plenty of interest that never turns into work, and the front desk describes it as being busy all day. In dental groups and DSOs that same description arrives from every location at once, which is the first sign the loss is at the desk rather than in the market.

DIFFERENTIAL — LIKELY CAUSES, MOST LIKELY FIRST

01
Access — first available is two to three weeks out

Demand that has to wait two weeks books somewhere with a next-week opening, so the pipeline is full of people who never became patients.

Appointment lead time averages 23 days against roughly 7 days for top performers. ADA HPI confirms the direction independently: the average new-patient wait at a general practice was 6.7 days in 2018 and 7.9 days in 2019, and is 16.0 days in 2025. Patients of record now wait 9.3 days, up from 5.9 in 2019.

Henry Schein One, 2026 Catalyst Index; ADA Health Policy Institute, 2026 Survey of Dental Practice, Table 22

NOT THIS IF — First available new-patient appointment is inside a week at every location, tested by calling rather than by reading the software.
02
Cancellations and no-shows are eating the booked schedule

Appointments are made and then vacated too late to refill, so booked capacity and shown capacity diverge.

Cancellation rate 12.9% (2025), down from 15.5% (2024); no-show rate 6.9% (2025), down from 7.4% (2024). Combined, roughly one in five booked appointments does not happen.

Planet DDS, 2026 Dental Industry Outlook Deep Dive (n = 8,500+ practices)

NOT THIS IF — Combined cancellation and no-show is well under about 12% and same-day refill is already routine.
03
Case acceptance — treatment is presented and not accepted

Patients arrive and are diagnosed, and the conversation at the chair does not end in a scheduled case.

Two publishers, two numbers, two definitions, and they must be carried together or not at all. Henry Schein One reports an industry average of 45% with the top 10% at 75%, and does not publish a definition. Planet DDS reports 58% for 2025 (57% in 2024), defines its metric as treatment marked accepted, scheduled or completed, and publishes the full distribution: 0–29% for 9.8% of practices, 30–49% for 25.7%, 50–69% for 35.7%, 70–89% for 19.7%, 90–100% for 9.1%. Do not average the two headline numbers and do not pick one.

Henry Schein One, 2026 Catalyst Index; Planet DDS, 2026 Deep Dive

NOT THIS IF — Acceptance is above 70% measured under Planet DDS's stated definition — that is the top 28.8% of practices — and the shortfall is downstream of the treatment conversation.
04
Case completion — accepted treatment never happens

The case is accepted, then not scheduled, or scheduled and never returned for, so it sits as unscheduled treatment dollars instead of production.

Case completion is 47% (2025), up from 42% (2024), measured as treatment plans created January–June 2025 completed by December 2025. Planet DDS's own conclusion is that completion, not acceptance, is the real constraint.

Planet DDS, 2026 Dental Industry Outlook and Deep Dive

NOT THIS IF — Unscheduled treatment dollars are small and stable. But read a zero gap carefully — Planet DDS found practices with a moderate acceptance-to-completion gap grew faster than practices with no gap at all, which suggests no gap can mean too little diagnosis rather than perfect follow-through.
05
Hygiene reappointment — the recall engine is not loaded

The most reliable source of future booked, shown work is the patient already in the chair, and they are leaving without a next appointment.

Hygiene reappointment within 12 months is 63% (2025), up from 60% (2024) — roughly four in ten hygiene patients leave with nothing booked. Hygienist daily production averages $1,058 against $8,764 for the practice, so an unloaded hygiene column drains the schedule quietly.

Planet DDS, 2026 Deep Dive (reappointment, daily production per provider-practice); Planet DDS 2025 Outlook (hygienist daily production, n ≈ 3,400+ Denticon practices)

NOT THIS IF — Reappointment is above the mid-60s, measured as booked at the chair rather than as call-backs attempted.

HOW TO TELL THEM APART

How to tell these apart in your own numbers

Each of these is a measurement you can run yourself, without us.

01 · Access — first available is two to three weeks out

Call your own practice as a new patient at 9am on a Monday, at every location, and record two things: days to first available new-patient appointment, and whether a human answered.

CONFIRMS IF

It exceeds 16 days, the ADA HPI 2025 general-practice average, or approaches Henry Schein One's 23-day industry lead time.

EXCLUDES IF

It is inside 7 days at every location — Henry Schein One's top-performer level — and the phone is answered live.

02 · Cancellations and no-shows are eating the booked schedule

Trailing 90 days from the practice management system: cancelled appointments and failed appointments as separate percentages of total scheduled. Then the percentage of vacated slots refilled the same day.

CONFIRMS IF

Combined cancellation and no-show approaches or exceeds 20%, against the published 12.9% and 6.9%, or same-day refill is under half.

EXCLUDES IF

Combined is under about 12% and vacated slots are routinely refilled.

03 · Case acceptance — treatment is presented and not accepted

Write down one definition and hold it for a year. Planet DDS's is public and usable: treatment marked accepted, scheduled or completed as a share of treatment presented. Measure per provider and per location, never pooled.

CONFIRMS IF

Under 50% on that definition — 35.5% of practices sit below 50% in Planet DDS's distribution, and 9.8% sit below 30%.

EXCLUDES IF

Above 70% on that definition, which is the top 28.8% of practices. Do not compare your number under one definition to Henry Schein One's 45% under an undisclosed one — the 13-point gap between the two publishers is probably a definition artifact and cannot be resolved from public documents.

04 · Case completion — accepted treatment never happens

Take every treatment plan created in a fixed six-month window, wait six months past the close of that window, and count the dollars actually completed. Report it beside acceptance for the same cohort, and beside the unscheduled treatment dollar balance.

CONFIRMS IF

Completion is far below acceptance and unscheduled treatment dollars grow quarter over quarter. The industry reference is 47% completion.

EXCLUDES IF

Completion sits close to acceptance and unscheduled dollars are flat. A narrow gap is not automatically a good sign.

05 · Hygiene reappointment — the recall engine is not loaded

The percentage of hygiene patients who physically left with their next appointment on the books, counted at the chair — not the percentage the software eventually recovered by phone.

CONFIRMS IF

Under 63%, the published industry average, or falling.

EXCLUDES IF

Above the mid-60s and the hygiene column is running full six weeks out.

WHAT RESOLVES EACH

What resolves this, and how you will know it resolved

Access — first available is two to three weeks out	Rx 03 · patient conversion →	Online booking and routing, same-day capacity matching, block-schedule changes. The first move is free: open new-patient capacity before buying any more demand for it.
Cancellations and no-shows are eating the booked schedule	Rx 03 · patient conversion →	Confirmation sequencing and a live short-call list so vacated slots refill the same day. This is desk work, not media work.
Case acceptance — treatment is presented and not accepted	Rx 03 · patient conversion →	Front-desk feedback loop and call-center instrumentation, so the treatment conversation is measured per provider. What does not work: more spend. A practice at 40% acceptance that doubles its new patients gets the same number of unaccepted cases twice.
Case completion — accepted treatment never happens	Rx 04 · marketing attribution →	Unscheduled treatment dollars on the monthly one-page readout, worked weekly by the desk under Rx 03 · intake-and-ops. The report is already in the practice management system; the failure is that nobody owns the list.
Hygiene reappointment — the recall engine is not loaded	Rx 03 · patient conversion →	Reappoint at the chair, before the patient stands up. Zero cost, no vendor, and it is the single highest-yield unpaid change available to a general practice.

WHAT "RESOLVED" LOOKS LIKE — Case acceptance and new-patient appointment lead time, measured per location

MEDIAN

Case acceptance 58% (Planet DDS, n = 8,500+, definition published) or 45% (Henry Schein One, definition not published — the two are not comparable and must not be averaged). New-patient appointment lead time 23 days (Henry Schein One) and 16.0 days (ADA HPI Table 22, 2025).

TOP DECILE

Case acceptance 75% for Henry Schein One's top 10%; 9.1% of practices sit at 90–100% in Planet DDS's distribution. Lead time approximately 7 days for Henry Schein One's top performers.

TARGET

Case acceptance in the 70–89% band — where 19.7% of practices sit, below the 9.1% at 90% and above — and first available new-patient appointment inside 10 days, against a 16.0-day industry average and a roughly 7-day top-performer level. A distribution position, not a promise, and stated against one written definition held constant.

Planet DDS, 2026 Deep Dive; Henry Schein One, 2026 Catalyst Index; ADA Health Policy Institute, 2026 Survey of Dental Practice, Table 22

HOW THIS DIFFERS BY SCALE

How this differs by scale

Single site	The entire pipeline is one front desk and one hygiene column, and the diagnostic is a phone call. Every fix in this document at single-site scale is behavioural and free: answer live, open new-patient blocks, reappoint at the chair, work the unscheduled treatment list. No agency is required to do any of it.
Group	Measure every metric per location and never pool. A group average of 55% case acceptance can be a site at 78% next to a site at 32% — and Planet DDS's distribution shows both exist in volume, with 9.8% of practices below 30% and 9.1% above 90%. Pooling is how a group spends a year fixing the wrong office.
Platform	At platform scale the pipeline is not converted until it is collected, so collection rate joins the same conversation: Henry Schein One puts 8+ location groups at 72% collections against 97% for the top 10%. Retention also degrades with size — 58% average at 8+ locations against 70% for solos — so a platform can improve acceptance and still see the pipeline stay thin because the base is leaking underneath it.

OTHER PRESENTATIONS — DSO & GENERAL DENTISTRY

A differential narrows the field. It does not replace the examination — that is what the six weeks are for. Every figure above is an industry reference range, not a client's numbers; those stay sealed. Sources are set out at /sources.

APPLY — 6 / QUARTER →